Pay Your Bill

Most of our companies bill you directly for your coverage. We strongly recommend that you pay directly to your insurance company.

Some of our companies offer online payment options:

New Payment Guidelines for Erie

As of March 1, 2016 credit cards will no longer be accepted for Erie’s Payment Plan A (pay in full) or Payment Plan B (pay within 60 days). Erie will be updating their “Pay My Bill” page on to provide the ability to pay with a debit card. The option to pay with a debit card will also remain available for those who prefer to call us to make their payment over the phone. Keep in mind, these new guidelines only affect policies on Payment Plans A and B.

As always, you can continue to pay over the phone with a debit card (or credit card for policies not on Payment Plans A or B), with bank routing and account information, or by stopping by the office where we also accept cash payments.

Not sure if this change will affect you? Give us a call! We are always happy to answer questions and address any concerns you may have.

prog pmt




Erie and Niagara Insurance Association

Allegany Insurance

For other companies, you can mail your check direct. If you don’t have your bill, be sure to write your policy number on your check. Here are addresses and phone numbers for several of our companies:

Genesee Patrons Coop Insurance Company
218 East Main Street
Batavia, New York 14020-2282
Phone (585) 343-7307

United Frontier Mutual Insurance Company
195 Davison Road
Lockport, New York 14094-3333.

Please give us a call if your company isn’t listed here or if you have unresolved problems that we can assist you with.

Privacy Policy | Information Security Policy | rochester seo